The opening of the April 11, N.Y. Times Op-Ed piece Faith-Based Medicine caught my attention,
RESPONSIBLE religious leaders will breathe a sigh of relief at the news that so-called intercessory prayer is medically ineffective. In a large and much touted scientific study, one group of patients was told that strangers would pray for them, a second group was told strangers might or might not pray for them, and a third group was not prayed for at all. The $2.4 million study found that the strangers' prayers did not help patients' recovery. The results of the study, led by Dr. Herbert Benson, a cardiologist and director of the Mind/Body Medical Institute near Boston, came as welcome news. That may sound odd coming from an ordained minister. But if it could ever be persuasively demonstrated that such prayer "works," our religious institutions and meeting places would be degraded to a kind of commercial enterprise, like Burger King, where one expects to get what one pays for.
Toward the end of the article, the author Raymond J. Lawrence (an episcopal priest and director of pastoral care at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center) asserts In my several decades as a clergyman working closely with doctors, I have never met one who prays with patients, nor one who prescribes intercessory prayer. There are other ways to express personal care and concern.
According to Raymond, if only the study would have consulted the material of who he considers the two major Christian theologians of the 20th century (Paul Tillich and Karl Barth) or The Lord's Prayer, the central prayer of Christendom, the researchers would have realized pleas for God to influence specific events in people's lives are not part of the Christian understanding of prayer. He seems to understand prayer as an expression of empathy that strengthens a caring community and brings comfort to those who are suffering.
I (Tom) would briefly like to give testimony that I greatly appreciated the prayer we received from physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals while at Mercy Hospital (a Roman Catholic institution associated with Duquesne University) when we lost Elise Faith in the NICU (neo-natal intensive care unit). And which we continue to receive from Westview Family Health (a broadly evangelical practice which established a urban outreach office a number of years ago) as our family walks through the issues with health that have been presented in the lives of both Eden and myself. In both of the these health practices the Presence of God is noticable and much of the work is offered up in prayer as part of wholistic medical care.
Why pray? Because all of life is lived in relationship and conversation with God the Father. Through the ministry of His Son Jesus, we have received the ability to enter into His Precense and the infilling of His Spirit in daily life. I agree that prayer is neither a magic spell ensuring a change in condition nor a commercial enterprise, but prayer is an encounter with the Other that is beyond us and walks with us in the real world. God has given us the good gifts which we employ in healing professions and the insight/patience into the complex situations that present themselves to us hour by hour requiring not only quick decision making but also the consideration of long term consequences. Prayer is a healthy statement that we depend upon God for all good gifts.
Physicans and other members of the hospital staff with weak understandings of their own faith (or no faith at all) at times will come face to face with Presence of God in their vocation and in the lives of those with whom they work. It is a shame that this Episcopalian priest and the Presbyterian hospital at which he serves have not had such a moment. We have had a number of opportunities to give testimony to the fact that the People of God and the Spirit of God do dwell together in unity AND we will continue to do such as God does not disappear during our regular visits to medical facilities. Praise be to God! Maybe some day my path will cross with Raymond enabling me to share another story for him to consider.