New Theory on Personality

Posted by theresa | Jun 17, 2009

Tonight I came up with a new theory on personality and I'd like to know if there is more evidence to back it up.  My theory is that a mother can identify the basic personality trait of her child based on how they nursed in the hours and days after birth.  I apologize up front to parents who bottle fed and maybe you can tell me if my theory has any basis in reality for your situation, but I can only speak from my experience.  So...  When I think back to the birth of my children and how they responded to nursing I see evidence of their personalities.  (Sadly Elise was too critical to nurse). 

  • Hayley knew what to do from the get-go; no hesitation, no problem. 
  • Ellen took a day or two of disinterest and caution before she decided this was a good thing. 
  • Eden didn't hold still for one second; she was like wrestling an alligator (yes, she bit too!). 
  • Lily knew what to do and was content to do it; never demanding, just content. 

And there you have it! 

  • Hayley goes with the flow. 
  • Ellen approaches with caution. 
  • Eden just keeps moving! 
  • Lily is the definition of contentment.

[Editor's note:  This grew out of our conversation posted at How intelligent are you?]

6 Comments & 0 Trackbacks of "New Theory on Personality"

    Interesting and I can see it too with my kids, though I am not sure I am not putting patterns on the facts. Adam seemed to easily nurse but didn't get enough nutrition so he had to be partly bottle fed, but he adapted and accepted both.That's much the way he is too: if doesn't always get things at first but can accept alternatives. Jibril didn't catch on but he was so small. He didn't have the patience needed it: very much so today. Firas was the best nurser: knew what he wanted and demanded it and wasn't willing to give it up when I was, i.e. stubborn, which is his most prominent characteristic.

    Posted by Karen, Jun 18 2009, 11:16

    I've been thinking of commenting here for a while, but I'm not sure I can gel my experience with your theory. Isaac, too, was never able to nurse. Jonathan took a few days to really get the hang of it (and extremely upset before the milk came in), but once he did he was avid and often. Noah took a few hours to try, but once he did figured it out right away no problems. Faith tried immediately with no problems as well. I'm not sure how that correlates, maybe my mom can add some insight.

    Posted by joyful, Jun 21 2009, 07:22

    I'm not much help, I'm afraid, either with what I see in my grandchildren or in my own kids. Our two have quite different personalities -- though with similarities as well, of course -- but if there was any difference in their nursing patterns, I didn't notice or don't remember.

    Posted by SursumCorda, Jun 21 2009, 11:41

    I thought of this post yesterday after watching Jonathan go careening down a hill at a park and get all scraped up, and then watching Noah ride his bike for the first time, and he checked out the brakes about 20 times.

    I doubt Jonathan checked the brakes the first time he rode his bike.

    Posted by Jon Daley, Jun 22 2009, 11:18

    I suspect there are at least two factors at work there: caution, and Noah's interest in anything mechanical.

    Posted by SursumCorda, Jun 22 2009, 13:11

    I knew the Daley clan would weigh in on this one! Happy to read your comments. Maybe the theory needs a wider sample size. Anyone else???

    Posted by Theresa, Jun 22 2009, 23:06